Buttercream Icing

by amandahorn in Cooking > Cake

1463 Views, 22 Favorites, 0 Comments

Buttercream Icing

WP_20170623_20_56_28_Pro_LI.jpg

There are lots of buttercream icing recipes out there, but this one is the very best! Ok, maybe I'm a little biased because it's my Mom's recipe ;-) She has been baking cakes for over 30 years and has tweaked her icing recipe over the years to develop this masterpiece. In this Instructable, with her permission, I am going to share how to make the best buttercream icing ever!

Ingredient list:

4 cups vegetable shortening

1 stick butter/margarine

1 1/4 cup water

2 Tablespoons vanilla extract

1 Tablespoon butter flavoring

3 bags (6 pounds) powdered sugar

Stand mixer (for these amounts, you will need at least a 7 quart mixing bowl - if your mixer is smaller, adjust the amounts accordingly)

Shortening

WP_20170623_20_34_26_Pro_LI.jpg
WP_20170623_20_35_13_Pro_LI.jpg

Measure out 4 cups of vegetable shortening; place in mixing bowl.

Pictured above is the best brand we've found for smooth icing since trans-fats were removed from Crisco brand.

Butter or Margarine

WP_20170623_20_42_48_Pro_LI.jpg

Add 1 stick (1/2 cup) butter or margarine.

Flavorings

WP_20170623_20_44_33_Pro_LI.jpg
WP_20170623_20_43_57_Pro_LI.jpg

Add 2 Tablespoons vanilla flavoring and 1 Tablespoon butter flavoring.

Water

WP_20170623_20_47_12_Pro_LI.jpg

Add 1 1/4 cups water.

Powdered Sugar

WP_20170623_20_47_56_Pro_LI.jpg
WP_20170623_20_51_00_Pro.jpg

Add 2 bags of powdered sugar to mixer and place on lowest speed. One way to prevent sloshing out of liquid is to place a dish towel around the bowl until mixture is somewhat combined.

Mix on low speed for approximately 2 minutes.

Then add the last bag of powdered sugar.

Mix

WP_20170623_20_50_12_Pro_LI.jpg
ivory.JPG
finished.JPG

Mix on medium speed for at least 2 minutes - to desired fluffiness.

Tint if desired. We used "ivory" icing color here to give it an ivory tint for a wedding cake.