A Miniature Beam Stirling Engine

by mikerobertgodfrey in Workshop > Metalworking

33609 Views, 163 Favorites, 0 Comments

A Miniature Beam Stirling Engine

P9050759.JPG
Making the World's Smallest Beam Stirling Engine

This Instructable covers the manufacturing processes for making a really small beam Stirling engine - to see the process in more detail, take a look at the embedded YouTube video.

To my knowledge, this is currently the world's smallest beam Stirling engine.

Supplies

Equipment:

  • Small lathe
  • Milling machine
  • Drill bits, taps and dies
  • Slitting saw
  • Soldering iron
  • Assorted files
  • Crucible
  • Blowtorch
  • Furnace
  • Vacuum chamber
  • 3D printer
  • General metalworking hand tools

Materials:

  • Brass stock
  • Steel stock
  • Aluminium stock
  • Titanium sheet
  • Wax-based resin or filament
  • Investment powder (+respiratory protection)
  • Mini ball bearings
  • Piano wire

Cylinder

P9050390 - frame at 0m7s.jpg
P9050394 - frame at 0m50s.jpg
P9050400 - frame at 2m35s.jpg
P9050404 - frame at 1m13s.jpg
P9050407 - frame at 0m19s.jpg
P9050408 - frame at 0m34s.jpg
P9050416 - frame at 0m31s.jpg
P9050424 - frame at 0m3s.jpg

The first step in making the cylinder is filing round brass bar square. An easy way to do this is by indexing the bar in the headstock and using two rollers to keep the file horizontal. Alternatively, it is possible to begin with square stock.

The profile of the cooling fins is up to you - here they are turned round but they can also be left square. The fins can be cut using a parting tool or a slitting saw rotating the opposite direction to the workpiece, as shown here.

The recess to accept the hot cap (shown later) is cut on one side of the cylinder using an endmill. On the opposite side, a 1mm hole must be drilled for the reciprocating rod connected to the displacer piston.

After parting the cylinder off, the last step is mounting it in a collet the opposite way around and tapping an M2 thread in the bottom, which will be used to bolt it to a base plate.

Displacer Piston

P9050485 - frame at 1m6s.jpg
P9050486 - frame at 0m23s.jpg
P9050489 - frame at 0m19s.jpg
P9050489 - frame at 0m32s.jpg

It is good practice to make reciprocating components as light as possible, so this part is made from aluminium. The displacer is made an intentionally loose fit in the hot cap to allow the flow of air around the outside. In one end of the displacer, an M1 thread is tapped to fit the 1 mm diameter reciprocating rod.

On the opposite end, a point is machined on the end of the displacer to reduce its drag coefficient.

Power Piston

P9050574 - frame at 0m49s.jpg
P9050576 - frame at 1m17s.jpg
P9050582 - frame at 0m38s.jpg

The power piston needs to be a precise fit in the main cylinder. This fit must be gas-tight but the power piston must be able to move freely.

This part is machined from 3mm diameter silver steel. A slot is cut in the end for the con rod to fit later and the perpendicular hole will receive the gudgeon pin.

A sapphire burnishing tool works well for polishing the surface and removing burrs, as it has the added benefit of work hardening the surface at the same time.

Central Pillar

P9050428 - frame at 1m28s.jpg
P9050436 - frame at 1m26s.jpg
P9050443 - frame at 2m13s.jpg
P9050447 - frame at 1m2s.jpg
P9050452 - frame at 0m56s.jpg
P9050460 - frame at 0m29s.jpg
P9050467 - frame at 0m37s.jpg
P9050472 - frame at 0m47s.jpg

The beam Stirling engine is defined by a horizontal beam that connects the flywheel to the power piston. This beam needs to pivot about a point, which leads us on to the central pillar.

The pillar is first turned with a slight taper and polished. A slitting saw and drill bit are used to create a slit and pivot point for the beam. The hole is cross-drilled to 0.7 mm and will later be opened up using a tapered broach during assembly to ensure a good fit with a tapered pin.

To clear a reciprocating fitting, a region near the bottom of the pillar needs to be milled away. Perpendicular to this feature, a slot is milled for the rod which connects the flywheel and displacer to pass through later.

Finally, the component is reversed in the collet and a thread is cut in the base of the pillar.

Bearing Housing

P9050493 - frame at 2m49s.jpg
P9050494 - frame at 0m3s.jpg
P9050494 - frame at 1m27s.jpg
P9050497 - frame at 0m49s.jpg
P9050502 - frame at 1m36s.jpg
P9050506 - frame at 0m40s.jpg
P9050511 - frame at 0m5s.jpg
P9050513 - frame at 0m17s.jpg

The bearing housing holds a pair of tiny 1.5mm ID ball races which support the flywheel. Using the same process as shown on the cylinder, two faces of the bearing housing are filed parallel. The hole for these bearings is cut using an endmill.

The top of the housing is filed round before separating it from the bar stock. Mounted the opposite way around in the collet, a thread is cut in the base of the part for mounting to the base plate.

The ball races are a snug press fit, pushed into place using a small vice.

Hot Cap

P9050688 - frame at 0m16s.jpg
P9050689 - frame at 0m57s.jpg
P9050690 - frame at 0m33s.jpg
P9050691 - frame at 1m20s.jpg

The hot cap is the part to which heat is applied to drive the engine. It is important to maximise the temperature differential between the cylinder and this part, so stainless steel is an ideal material, thanks to its low thermal conductivity.

The thin wall of the hot cap is formed by drilling, then boring a hole in the stock. It is then parted off and reversed in the chuck to face off the closed end.

Printing, Casting and Machining the Flywheel

Screenshot 2023-04-16 175335.jpg
Screenshot 2023-04-16 175519.jpg
Photon slicer.PNG
P9050519 - frame at 0m20s.jpg
P9050589 - frame at 0m31s.jpg
P9050600 - frame at 0m16s.jpg
P9050629 - frame at 0m39s.jpg
P9050631 - frame at 0m43s.jpg
P9050635 - frame at 0m15s.jpg
P9050635 - frame at 0m54s.jpg
P1110122 - frame at 2m4s.jpg
P9050639 - frame at 2m56s.jpg
P9050640 - frame at 0m24s.jpg
P9050643 - frame at 0m1s.jpg
P9050649 - frame at 0m41s.jpg
P9050683 - frame at 2m41s.jpg
P9050685 - frame at 1m21s.jpg
P9050699 - frame at 0m3s.jpg

It's certainly possible to skip most of these steps by opting for a simpler flywheel with flat spokes that can be machined but this seemed like a good opportunity to share the investment casting process.

First up, the flywheel is modelled in CAD. After some experimentation, we decided to add some solid support and a stub to the model at this stage rather than leaving the support up to the slicing software.

We have an Anycubic Photon resin printer, so we sliced the STL in Photon Workshop using the settings below. (You'll notice we printed two flywheels at the same time to have a spare.)

  • Layer thickness: 0.05 mm
  • Normal exposure time: 21 s
  • Bottom exposure time: 80 s
  • Bottom layers: 5
  • Z lift speed: 0.5 mm/s

Once complete, the print is carefully removed from the bed, then washed and cured as you would for a normal print.

Using a soldering iron, several wax sprues are added to the model, which form a path for the molten metal to flow through during casting. The next step is mounting the model into a flask, into which investment slurry is added.

N.B. When using investment powder, always wear a suitable mask - the silica particles can cause serious lung damage if inhaled.

The powder and water are mixed together to form the slurry. The mixing process agitates the mixture, which inevitably introduces air bubbles. These can be removed by degassing the slurry in a vacuum chamber.

The mixture is then poured into the flask containing the 3D-printed flywheel and the flask is set aside for a couple of hours to let the slurry cure.

Once cured, the rubber flask base can be peeled off. The wax geometry is now surrounded by ceramic and can be melted out using a furnace. A starting temperature of 120°C is used, followed by a series of temperature ramps up to 730 °C, which melts the wax, then burns off any residue and fully cures the investment mixture. 

The flask is removed from the furnace at around 650°C to pour the molten metal into what is now hopefully a flywheel-shaped cavity. The hot flask is placed over a hole in the vacuum chamber to help suck the metal into the mould cavity. In parallel, some brass is melted in a crucible using a blowtorch. When the brass is completely molten, it is poured into the top of the mould.

The flask and mould are quenched in water, which breaks up the mould and releases the casting. After checking the casting for defects, the excess material can be removed using a combination of hand tools, machining and milling. Leaving the central stub oversize provides a convenient surface for gripping the flywheel in the watchmakers' lathe.

Now that the flywheel is a more manageable size, it can be finished with some lighter cuts in the watchmakers' lathe and a 1.5 mm hole for the main shaft drilled in the centre.

Painting is of course optional too but the spokes of this flywheel were coloured using red enamel paint.

Base Plate

P9050651 - frame at 0m14s.jpg
P9050658 - frame at 1m46s.jpg
P9050665 - frame at 0m42s.jpg
P9050692 - frame at 1m25s.jpg

All of the components need to fixed in place, so a base plate is made from a small piece of flat brass. The outer shape of this part isn't too important but the relative positions of the holes need to be precise. An easy way to get this right is using coordinate drilling with a DRO but manual measurement would be sufficient too.

Con Rods, Beams and Pins

P9050693 - frame at 1m18s.jpg
P9050693 - frame at 3m56s.jpg
P9050695 - frame at 1m29s.jpg
P9050703 - frame at 0m1s.jpg
P9050712.JPG
P9050717 - frame at 0m27s.jpg
P9050719 - frame at 0m46s.jpg
P9050721 - frame at 0m35s.jpg
P9050701 - frame at 0m1s.jpg

The con rods and beam are made from titanium shim, which is thin enough to be cut with scissors. The holes are drilled using a small high-speed drill and the corners are rounded with a needle file.

The beam and connecting rods are pinned in place with a 0.8 mm diameter tapered pins. These are made from short segments of piano wire. Each piece is faced off and deburred in the lathe, and a slight taper is applied using a diamond stone and burnisher.

A different approach was required for the pin connecting two con rods as there isn't enough metal to press fit a tapered pin here. This pin is cross-drilled with a 0.4 mm tapered pin which stops it from falling out.

Crank

P9050729 - frame at 0m56s.jpg
P9050729 - frame at 1m0s.jpg

The crank comprises a brass ring with a radially threaded screw and a small pin. The pin is offset by 1.5 mm, which results in a piston stroke of 3 mm.

Assembly and Testing

P9050723 - frame at 0m23s.jpg
P9050723 - frame at 0m41s.jpg
P9050723 - frame at 1m15s.jpg
P9050723 - frame at 2m17s.jpg
P9050724 - frame at 0m14s.jpg
P9050728 - frame at 0m53s.jpg
P9050729 - frame at 1m38s.jpg
P9050731 - frame at 0m13s.jpg
P9050732 - frame at 3m58s.jpg
P9050733 - frame at 1m27s.jpg
P9050733 - frame at 2m24s.jpg
P9050783 - frame at 0m6s.jpg
P9050732 - frame at 2m35s.jpg

The three main components are mounted onto the baseplate first. The main pillar is threaded into the end of a pencil here but could be mounted using the same approach as the cylinder and bearing housing if preferred.

The crank is bolted onto the flywheel axle using a small screwdriver.

A dab of watch oil is used to lubricate the piston, which sits inside the cylinder. Next, the beam and connecting rods are fitted. The displacer is fitted into the other cylinder recess and the displacer con rod passes through the slot in the pillar.

The hot cap is a simple press-fit into the recess that was machined in the cylinder with the endmill.

Of course, the final step is testing if the engine runs over a small flame.

Thanks for reading!